Welcome, Reviewer!

Thank you for joining the esteemed group of reviewers for GERECHTIKEIT: Jurnal Riset Peradaban Hukum. Your expertise is invaluable to our commitment to high-quality scholarly publishing. Please follow this guide to conduct a thorough and constructive review within the framework of our double-blind review process.

Double-Blind Review Process

Our journal employs a double-blind review process to ensure fairness and impartiality. Both the author(s) and the reviewer(s) identities are concealed throughout the review process.

Reviewer's Responsibilities

  1. Timeliness:

    • We appreciate your prompt response. Please adhere to the agreed-upon timeline for completing your review.
  2. Confidentiality:

    • Maintain confidentiality throughout the review process. Do not disclose any information about the manuscript or your review to external parties.
  3. Constructive Feedback:

    • Provide detailed and constructive feedback to assist authors in enhancing the quality of their work.
  4. Evaluation Criteria:

    • Originality, Methodology, Clarity and Structure, Contribution, References.
  5. Conflicts of Interest:

    • Identify and notify the editorial office of any conflicts of interest that may compromise the objectivity of your review.

Reviewing Process

  1. Accessing the Manuscript:

    • Log in to the GERECHTIKEIT: Jurnal Riset Peradaban Hukum.
    • Retrieve the assigned manuscript from your dashboard.
  2. Review Form:

    • Complete the review form provided in the system.
    • Clearly express your comments, suggestions, and recommendations.
  3. Recommendation:

    • Provide a clear recommendation regarding the acceptance, minor revisions, major revisions, or rejection of the manuscript.
  4. Confidential Comments to the Editor:

    • Include any confidential comments to the editor that may aid in the decision-making process.

Finalizing the Review

Upon completing your review, submit the feedback through the GERECHTIKEIT: Jurnal Riset Peradaban Hukum. If you anticipate any delays or encounter challenges during the review process, please inform the editorial office promptly.


Your dedication to maintaining the quality of academic research is greatly appreciated. Thank you for your invaluable contribution to GERECHTIKEIT: Jurnal Riset Peradaban Hukum.

For further queries or clarification, please contact the editorial team.